Buying new in France? You’re paying for the social housing downstairs, and you’re paying twice
In French real estate development, there is a rule everyone knows except the person writing the check. When you buy a newly built apartment, the advertised price per square meter doesn’t just pay for your home. It also absorbs the discount granted on the social housing units in the same building, which are sold to social landlords at half the market price.
The developer loses nothing. He simply shifts his margin onto the units he sells at full price. The difference is paid by private buyers. And they pay it twice.
First at the time of purchase, without knowing it. No sales brochure, no agent will ever tell you that part of your price per square meter is funding the subsidized apartment downstairs.
Then through taxes and payroll contributions, which feed the subsidies without which a rent-capped unit can never break even.
Industry insiders have a word for this: péréquation immobilière, or real estate cross-subsidization.
A concrete case: Les Balcons de Belledonne, in Biviers
Take Les Balcons de Belledonne, a residential development in the Évêquaux neighborhood of Biviers, in the hills above Grenoble. Nobody moves there for the bargain prices.
I obtained a reservation contract signed in 2021 between the developer and the social landlord. The development has 29 units, five of which were acquired by the Société Dauphinoise pour l’Habitat (SDH), a regional social housing company.
The 2021 prices:
- paid by the social landlord: €2,140/m²
- local market price: €4,000 to €5,000/m²
The social landlord is therefore paying between 43% and 54% of market price. Half price was no exaggeration.
Let’s run a rough estimate, with a conservative assumption of 60 m² on average for the five social units, or 300 m² in total. The gap with market value comes to between €560,000 and €860,000 across the project. The developer is not running a charity: that shortfall has to be recovered somewhere. Spread across the 24 units sold to private buyers, that’s €23,000 to €36,000 per buyer. The price of a new car, slipped into your deed without anyone mentioning it. This isn’t accounting to the cent: the result depends on actual unit sizes and on how land costs are allocated between units. But the direction is beyond doubt.
Some will object that this gap isn’t a discount on the true value of the square meter. Part of it reflects the margin the developer forgoes on the social units, and part reflects land costs that are sometimes allocated differently between market-rate and social units. That’s true, and that is precisely the problem. The developer doesn’t lose money; he reallocates his margin across the entire project. If he doesn’t take it at the bottom, he takes it at the top. From you. For the buyer, only one comparison matters: in a project with no social units at all, he would have paid less.
The second bill: the taxpayer’s
The taxpayer, for his part, isn’t covering the price gap: the private buyer has already settled that one. He is paying for something else, the capped rent. A unit rented far below market never breaks even on its own, and it wouldn’t break even any better if the landlord had bought it at full price. So the social landlord stays afloat on loans drawn from regulated savings funds, public grants, a reduced VAT rate, and a long-term exemption from property tax. That exemption, by the way, doesn’t make the money vanish: the lost revenue is made up by other owners, the ones who pay France’s zombie property tax, the taxe foncière, at full rate.
And when the social landlord belongs to the Action Logement group, as SDH does today, part of its resources comes from the mandatory employer contribution to housing construction, set at 0.45% of payroll. One more levy, once again paid by the people who work and buy.
So the buyer of a new home is tapped twice for the same social housing unit: once at the developer’s counter for its price, and once at the government’s counter for its rent. This is redistribution, and I have no objection to debating it. The principle of social mix, after all, is openly voted on and embraced, written into law and into local zoning plans. What isn’t embraced is the bill. It hides inside a price per square meter. It is a textbook case of the French habit of treating citizens like children: nobody asks your opinion, nobody even tells you, they just help themselves.
What the planning office told me
I’m not speaking as a theorist. I once put together a small project of my own: three units, two one-bedroom apartments and a three-bedroom duplex. The town planning office gave me the green light without any trouble, along with a condition slipped in as if it were a detail: one of the three had to become social housing.
I asked, naively, whether the social landlord would buy it from me at market price. The answer came back without the slightest embarrassment: no, at construction cost. In other words, one unit out of three would have been taken from me at the price of cinder blocks, and I would have been expected to say thank you.
There you have the mechanism in all its glory. You carry the risk, you buy the land, you finance, you build. And at the end, the local authority forces you to hand over a unit without the land value or the margin. Yet you paid for that land in full. And who sets these quotas in the zoning documents? Rarely the mayor you elected, and more and more often the inter-municipal council, a body no one elects directly.
Having it both ways
There is one last layer to this story, and it may be the juiciest. Some developers have financial ties to the very social landlords they sell to.
In the development where I lived, the developer was Safilaf. The three social units in the project went to SDH. Now, Safilaf, one of the leading developers in the Isère department, long counted SDH among its subsidiaries. As recently as 2014, France’s interministerial social housing inspectorate described SDH as a company whose main shareholder is a local real estate developer.
The developer sells to the landlord, and the landlord belongs to the developer. The “social” price is negotiated within the family, the private buyer makes up the difference, and the taxpayer covers the rest. That is having it both ways.
The bare minimum we should do
Until we finally do away with the SRU law, the French statute that requires municipalities to meet social housing quotas, and with the whole quota machinery it has inspired, one commonsense measure would at least be to require price transparency.
The system itself is no secret: the quotas are public, and so are the zoning plans. What stays in the dark is the number, the one that would let buyers know how much they are paying for others. That is the number that needs to come out.
In practical terms, every off-plan reservation contract (VEFA, in French) should state in black and white:
- the number of social housing units in the project;
- the price per square meter at which they are sold to the social landlord;
- the gap with the price offered to private buyers.
These figures exist. They are written into the contract between the developer and the social landlord; the proof is that I have one right in front of me. This isn’t about creating new information, only about giving it to the person who pays.
Anyone who funds part of a neighbor’s home deserves at least to know how much. For now, the preference is that he not find out. And a system that survives only so long as the people funding it don’t understand it isn’t solidarity. It is a levy that dares not speak its name.